It is one of those days when you feel you mind just halts to think and even when you think you have come out of a particular thought, you realize soon that you are actually not out of it.
Except the fact that I was living and working in United States in 2001 and happen to see the 2nd World Trade Center tower being attacked live on TV – I do not have a family or friend who perished on that fateful day.
But, not only just on 9/11 but any conversation of what happened on that day, brings lot of emotions out of me.
There is a lot to write, and I just have not done it before. Reasons are many, but the fact is, it is very difficult to write. Will try again, now.
Questions
In all these years before and after 9/11, when ever I come across some TV anchor or an article talking about America’s “preparedness” – I feel angry and upset that the person does not know what they are talking about.
No country in the world can be prepared for such a barbaric act. An act where a band of brain-washed radicals are ready to throw their life and not only that but also use any means possible to pull innocent people to barge in their medieval agenda. Yet, it is not so much about being prepared, but about how America reacted in the days, weeks, months and years to come, that redefined America, to the entire world.
Yes, since then America did lot of mistakes, leaders did not act as leaders.
Yes, America’s actions since then has created more questions and concerns, than even before 9/11.
Yet, a leader’s guidance or mis-guidance (depending on your vantage point) should not and does not define or reflect any or every American, then and since then.
There is only one America
Beyond the inexplicable tragedy, I do not ever think that any other nation in the world could even take such a blow. Yes, America has fought and still fights wars. Yes, many around the world blame on their imperialistic attitude. We may disagree with them on many, but again, there is only one America, which took the blow. While I disagree with almost everything President Bush did since then, on that day – possibly only on that day – I saw him and respected him as a President of a great nation. I still debate in my mind whether it was because of the President that the entire nation united behind their leader or, was it a natural quality of the country-men.
We live at a time, where there is hardly any unity with in a country and to get the entire nation listen to you and to act as their leader, family member and guide through the chaos and uncertainty is what is expected out of a leader. And on that, I believe President Bush did what he was supposed to do. [ Surely for the last time. ]
The real debate
I often wonder, how could have any nation reacted to such an act. You don’t have any reference point for you to compare with or frame your thoughts through sadness. You have many since then – you see stupid TV networks playing with months and dates and trying to compare anything and everything with 9/11. But there wasn’t any on 9/11.
When extraordinary things happen and when such an event affect 100′s and 1000′s of people – what do you do ? And I think American people answered that for the world. We may disagree on many, but they faced, faced it bold and with sadness.
Leadership
When the crowd unites behind their leader, more than ever the leader shoulders much more responsibility. America stood united behind their leader, counting and trusting President Bush. Let us pause on that. We live in world where we hardly follow what is being told. Even enforcement hardly works. I am writing this from India and such an union, even in an extraordinary situation is impossible to achieve. There are many nations like that and we read about them almost daily in the news papers. Yet, the society of America, their thought process, their discipline, their unity shined among the tragedy. Yet, that trust was broken over the years to come since then. The same country could not know what to believe in, what is moving and what is standing for them to hold. It was not their fault, but that of the leader who violated and abused that trust.
Reaction
This is not about the leader, but of the people. The world we live in, there are riots on riots. When a barbaric act is pushed on you, when innocent lives are lost – you do see it as unnatural and as an ‘act of war’. Your reasoning stops, you reactions starts. America reacted. There are those who point back as what all America and other nations alike have done in different parts of the world. True. War is most often unjust! I do not try to justify what happened before and after – but I disagree even with what happened before and after and more particularly on 9/11. Riot on riot, blood for blood is not just vengeance, it is equally unjust as what lead to rioting and blood-shed.
Face of the nation
People vote out of trust. The trust that their leader will do good for the country, they will act responsible. Time and again, we find such leaders violating that trust. But when they do, those (irresponsible) leaders do not pay the price, it is those who voted them into power who pays. So, it is a double-whammy – not only they see a person change but equally they pay an high price. I debate in my mind as why in the world they reelected President Bush back into power. But think about it, when there was so much of chaos, the guy who is shouting aloud on the mic gets benefit of doubt.
Reference Points
There is no reference point to 9/11, except that 9/11 became a reference point to the entire world. It meant many things to many. It became a default reference point for terrorism. It became a reference point for waging wars, extreme and inexplicable sorrow, leadership during crisis, politics, irresponsible leadership, country dealing with colossal financial crisis because of actions since then etc. The list is long and almost endless.
The Loss
None of those who perished on that fateful day, deserve such a cruelty. The argument of those who inflicted that terror, was not with them but with the leader of the nation, their actions – past and present. If you had disagreement in the way America reacted, a sneak attack and barbaric act is not going to contain it. So, you as a terrorist failed in that agenda too.
The Change
When ever people say that their world changed since 9/11 for ever – I really believe the change that is referenced is not uniform across all those. In other words, there is no unity in that change, given the event, events since then. The change out of that meant and still means different things to different people.
- It changed the world view of America for ever. Events since then changed them again.
- It changed the view of the world itself
- It changed the limits of a nation
- It changed the limits of nation’s anger
- It changed the meaning of leadership
- It changed the definition of responsibility
- It changed the scope and volume of the word ‘mistake’
- It change the belief system
- It changed the meaning and purpose of religion
- It changed the way as how many neglected the value of human life
- It changed the way we care about ourselves, our families, our dear ones
- It changed the view of what we hold as true values and what we do not
- It changed us as who we are and who we want to be
- It changed what we hold, what we hold dear
- It changed what we want to leave behind for our future generations
The Unchanged
What did not and will not change is the worlds thoughts, prayers and sympathy toward a great nation – United States of America, toward each and every one of them who perished, each and every one of them who lost their lives since then, because of its leaders’ decisions, each and everyone family which got affected in so many different ways.